Interior of a small manufacturing facility where a general counsel reviews compliance documents at a desk among policy binders.

Employment Law for Employers | Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach

Asking About Criminal Records? Get Clear Answers Before You Hire

A single line on an application can shape your hiring process, your paperwork and your legal exposure. Know where the lines are before you use the answers.

By Kristina E. Wilson · Published November 8, 2026

You’re reviewing applications, and the form asks about criminal history. Can you ask, and what can you do with the answer?

In Florida, a private employer can generally ask about criminal history. The real risk is in how the answer is used. A blanket rule that rejects anyone with any record can create legal exposure, even when the question itself was lawful.

The Short Answer for Florida Private Employers

A private employer in Florida can generally ask about criminal history, but the question starts a process rather than ending it. Two sets of rules apply at once. Florida has its own law, the Florida Civil Rights Act of 1992. That act applies to an employer with 15 or more employees for each working day in each of 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year, under Fla. Stat. § 760.02. Your headcount decides whether the state act reaches you, so check it first.

Asking the question is not, by itself, the main legal risk. What matters is when you ask, what you do with the answer, and whether your decision is tied to the job. Consistency matters too. The same question, asked the same way to every candidate for the same job, is easier to defend than a question asked only of some people.

If you're deciding whether to keep a criminal-history question on your application, our team can walk through the job, the record and the hiring steps with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

A lawyer in an office reads documents at a desk.

Why a Blanket Exclusion Creates Risk

A blanket rule that rejects everyone with any record is the riskiest version of this question. A rule can look fair on paper and still create exposure if it hits certain groups harder.

Disparate treatment is different. It means applying a harsher standard to people because of a protected trait. Intent matters in that claim, and it can arise even when the rule looks neutral.

The arrest record deserves its own look. An arrest is not the same as a conviction, and the final outcome of an arrest matters. The FBI’s arrest disposition guidance explains what these outcomes are and how they are recorded. A rule that treats an arrest with no conviction the same as a conviction is harder to defend.

The Individualized Assessment Approach

An individualized assessment means looking at each record against the specific job before you decide. Three factors guide most reviews: how serious the offense was, how much time has passed, and what the job requires day to day. Ask whether the offense has a real link to the duties. A financial-crime record may matter for a bookkeeping role and matter less for a warehouse role. A driving offense may matter more for a delivery driver.

Give the applicant a chance to respond before you decide. Ask for their explanation of the record, any errors they see, and any steps they have taken since. Write down what they say.

Here is a plain example. Two candidates apply for the same cashier job. One has an old, minor theft conviction and a clean record since. The other has a recent fraud conviction. A documented review may reach different results for each candidate, and the reasons should be written down. The outcome depends on the facts.

Federal Background Check Paperwork

Be careful with the acronym. On this page, FCRA means the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, not Florida’s Civil Rights Act. Confirm the exact requirements before you act on a report.

Skipping a step is a mistake that is easy to avoid with a written checklist. Build the checklist into your hiring workflow so every report follows the same path. Keep a copy of each notice and each applicant response in the file.

Florida Law: The Civil Rights Act and Deadlines

Florida’s Civil Rights Act makes it unlawful for an employer to refuse to hire someone because of a listed trait. The listed traits are race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, handicap and marital status, as set out in Fla. Stat. § 760.10. Criminal history is not on that list. The question is whether a record policy is used to discriminate because of one of those traits. The same section also bars limiting or classifying applicants in ways that deprive people of job opportunities for those reasons.

Deadlines are short.

A civil lawsuit under the Florida act has its own clock. Under Fla. Stat. § 760.11, it must be filed within one year after the earlier of a reasonable-cause determination by the commission or the issuance of a Notice of Right to Sue by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. If neither issues within 180 days after the complaint, the action may be filed within 18 months. If a court finds a violation, remedies can include back pay and compensatory damages. Punitive damages are capped at $100,000.

What a Background Check Can Include

A typical background check covers identity and criminal records. For some roles, it also covers employment or education history. The scope depends on the job and on the source of each record.

The FBI’s guidance also covers fingerprint-based criminal-history checks used for employment. Those checks return records that should be read alongside the disposition of each arrest.

Records can also be sealed or expunged. Search results can contain errors, and an applicant may need to address them. How far back a search reaches depends on the source and the rules that govern it.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

A Practical Hiring Process That Reduces Risk

Use a written process so every candidate for a role gets the same review. Five steps cover most situations.

  1. Decide which roles truly need a criminal history review. Write down the job duties that make it relevant.
  2. Ask the question at the same stage for every candidate in that role. Consider limiting the question to convictions unless the job calls for more.
  3. If a record raises a concern, run the individualized review. Write down the offense, the date, the job duties and the applicant’s response.
  4. If a third-party report is part of the decision, follow the federal notice and permission steps in order.
  5. Apply the same written standard to every candidate for the role. Keep a record of each decision.

Common Mistakes Florida Employers Make With Criminal History Questions

The most common mistake is a blanket rule that rejects anyone with any record. That rule ignores the date, the offense and the job. Other mistakes follow the same pattern.

  • Asking about records the business does not need, without writing down why the question matters for the role.
  • Skipping the notice step when a third-party report drives a rejection.
  • Applying different standards to applicants and current employees without a documented reason.
  • Treating a handbook statement as a binding rule, or assuming it has no effect. Under Quaker Oats Co. v. Jewell, a handbook policy statement does not create enforceable contract rights unless it expressly says the manual is a separate employment contract.

Write your criminal-history policy clearly anyway. It guides every person who makes hiring decisions.

Local Context for Miami-Dade and South Florida Employers

KEW Legal has offices in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. The firm works with business owners and employers across Miami-Dade County and South Florida, including clients in Miami, Doral, Brickell, Aventura and Fort Lauderdale.

Employers in other Florida counties face the same federal and state rules discussed here. The framework does not change at the county line.

Hiring questions often come up alongside employee handbooks, staffing agreements and vendor contracts. The firm handles those business matters too, so the hiring question can be reviewed in that wider context.

A woman's hands fill out a job application form at a desk in an office.

Talk Through Your Hiring Question With KEW Legal

If you’re weighing whether to keep a criminal-history question on your application, or you have a background report on a finalist, you don’t have to sort out these rules alone. Kristina E. Wilson and the firm’s lawyers, including Natalie Martinez, can review the job duties, the record and the steps you’ve taken so far.

Frequently Asked Questions

The answer must still be used within federal and state discrimination rules.

Does the Florida Civil Rights Act cover small employers?

It covers employers with 15 or more employees for each working day in 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year.

If you’re deciding how to handle a criminal-history question right now, reach out. The initial consultation is free, confidential and carries no obligation to continue. Call 305-990-2300 or send a message through our contact page.

The engagement of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. The information on this website is general information about KEW Legal and the services we offer; it does not constitute legal advice and is intended for informational purposes only. Accessing this website or contacting our firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. KEW Legal, 16690 Collins Ave Ste 1101, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160.

How KEW Legal Helps Employers Handle Hiring Questions

Application and Policy Review

We review your application forms, background check forms and hiring policies before they go into use.

Practical Guidance for Managers

Clear, written instructions help the people making hiring decisions apply the same process every time.

Careful Process, Documented Decisions

A consistent, well-documented process helps employers respond to questions about how a hire was made.

Outside General Counsel

Ongoing access to counsel for everyday employment questions, not only when a problem has already started.

Don't Make a Decision on a Record Alone

A criminal history is one fact in a hiring decision, not the whole picture. Before you act on what an application or background check shows, talk through the process with counsel.

Common Questions Before You Hire

What Your Application Asks

The wording of a question and where it appears on a form can change how it should be handled.

Background Checks

How a check is ordered, used and documented matters as much as what it reveals.

Documenting the Decision

Keep a clear record of how each hiring decision was made and the reasons behind it.

Questions After Hiring

Concerns about an employee's criminal history can come up well after the hire date.

Related practice areas

Request a Consultation

Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.

Call Now — Free Consultation (305) 990-2300