A general counsel reviews compliance documents at a desk surrounded by policy binders and operational records inside a small manufacturing facility.

Employment Law for Employers | Coral Gables & Sunny Isles Beach

Build a Background Check Policy Before You Need One

Written screening rules help your hiring decisions stay consistent, documented and easier to explain when questions come up.

By Kristina E. Wilson · Published November 11, 2026

If you’re deciding how to screen job applicants, you need rules you can apply the same way every time. A background check policy for employers in Florida is a written set of rules. It says which checks you run, for which jobs, at what point in hiring, and who makes the final call. Florida law also helps employers who complete a documented investigation before hiring. In certain lawsuits, the employer is presumed not to have been negligent in hiring. Here’s what that means for your policy.

What a Background Check Policy Covers and Who Needs One

A background check policy covers which checks run, which positions they apply to, when they happen, and who reviews the results. It applies to new applicants and, if you choose, to people already on your payroll.

A written policy turns a judgment call into a repeatable process. That makes it easier to explain a hiring decision later. Roles that involve driving, handling money, or working inside other people’s homes deserve the clearest written rules.

Florida’s main anti-discrimination law defines an employer as a business with 15 or more employees for each working day in each of 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year (Florida Civil Rights Act definitions). Smaller businesses still benefit from a written process, because consistency is easier to defend.

If you're writing or updating a background check policy and aren't sure which steps fit your roles, our team is glad to talk it through with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Warehouse worker with a clipboard and checklist, checking inventory on the shelves.

Criminal Record Checks Under Florida Law

A criminal background check counts toward Florida’s negligent hiring presumption only when you request it from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and obtain information from the Florida Crime Information Center system (Florida negligent hiring statute). The result reflects that system as of the date of your request. Write that date in the file. A result is a snapshot, not an ongoing record.

Your policy can also address how you hire, not just what you check. Your policy can also address how you hire, not just what you check.

Federal and State Rules That Shape Your Screening

Florida law makes it unlawful for an employer to refuse to hire, fire, or treat someone differently in pay or conditions because of race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, handicap, or marital status (Florida employment practices statute). Those categories are broader than many owners expect. A screening rule that limits or classifies applicants in a way that would deprive or tend to deprive them of employment opportunities, because of any of those categories, can create a claim.

A complaint about an unlawful employment practice must be filed within 365 days of the alleged violation, under § 760.11. A complaint may be filed with the Florida Commission on Human Relations, the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, or a state fair-employment-practice agency, under § 760.11. The earliest filing date counts (Florida remedies statute).

Federal anti-discrimination rules also apply to employers. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission publishes guidance for employers (EEOC employer guidance).

Checks Beyond the Criminal Record

Florida’s negligent hiring statute lists the steps of a background investigation, including a criminal background check, reasonable efforts to contact references and former employers, and a job application with questions about convictions and civil actions. It also lets employers choose between a driver license record check, when that check is relevant to the work, and an interview (Florida negligent hiring statute).

  • A criminal record check, as described above.
  • A reasonable effort to contact references and former employers about the applicant’s suitability for the job.
  • A written application that asks whether the applicant has been convicted of a crime, with the type of crime, the date, and the penalty. It should also ask whether the applicant has been a defendant in a civil case for an intentional tort.
  • A driver license record check, with written authorization, when the job calls for driving and the record can reasonably be obtained. The statute also allows an interview of the applicant as part of the investigation.

Keep the questions the same for every applicant in the same role.

Timing: When Each Step Must Happen

Finish the investigation before you make the hire. The presumption depends on a background investigation that includes the checks the statute requires, conducted before hiring the employee, that did not reveal any information reasonably showing the person was unsuitable for the particular work or for employment in general. A check run after the offer is accepted doesn’t meet that timing rule.

Plan your calendar so the application, references, and criminal check are done before the final decision. If a result raises a concern, write down the job-related reason before you decide.

Keep your records for at least 365 days after the decision. Application forms, written authorizations, reference notes, and the date of each check all belong in the file. Without dates, a reviewer has to rebuild events from memory, and that is hard to do after months have passed.

Building the Policy Step by Step

  1. List each open role and its core duties.
  2. Match each check to a real duty. A driving record check fits a delivery role, for example.
  3. Build one application form with the conviction and civil-action questions the statute lists.
  4. Set one reference process. Decide who you contact, which questions you ask, and where the notes go.
  5. Decide how the policy will read. Handbook policy statements don’t create enforceable contract rights unless the manual says, in specific language, that it is a separate employment contract (Quaker Oats Co. v. Jewell).
  6. Write the job-related reason for each rejection or firing decision. Apply that reason to everyone in the same role.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Common Mistakes Employers Make

  • Hiring first and checking later. The presumption depends on an investigation done before hiring.
  • Skipping the investigation. Choosing not to investigate doesn’t create a presumption that you were careless. But you give up the presumption a completed investigation provides (Florida negligent hiring statute).
  • Knowingly false reference answers. Immunity for disclosing information about a current or former employee upon request of the prospective employer or of the employee does not apply if it is shown by clear and convincing evidence that the information was knowingly false or violated a civil right under chapter 760 (Florida employer immunity statute).
  • Assuming “at-will” means no limits. Florida is an employment-at-will state (Gessner v. Southern Co.). An at-will employee may be let go at any time, but not for a reason the law prohibits, such as retaliation or unlawful discrimination (Laguerre v. Palm Beach Newspapers).
  • Assuming your handbook is a contract, or assuming it isn’t. The answer turns on explicit wording in the manual, not on the label “handbook.”
  • Applying different standards to the same job. Different rules for similar applicants make it hard to show that a decision rested on the job, not on a protected trait.

Why Employers Work With KEW Legal

KEW Legal is a Florida business law firm with offices in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. The firm acts as outside general counsel for business owners and investors across Miami-Dade and South Florida. Employment law for employers is one of the practice areas the firm handles, alongside partnership disputes, vendor contracts, commercial leases, and business succession. Kristina E. Wilson is responsible for this page. Natalie Martinez is also one of the firm’s lawyers.

Screening policies rarely stand alone. They touch your handbook, your contracts with outside vendors, and your ownership documents. Our team reviews a policy alongside those documents, so the rules you write fit how your business actually runs.

Cropped view of an unidentified woman filling out a job application form at an employer's office desk.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should a background check policy for employers in Florida include?

It should list each check, the jobs it applies to, when it runs before hiring, and who reviews the results.

Does a criminal record check help against a negligent hiring claim?

It can. A check requested from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, using Florida Crime Information Center information, is part of the investigation the statute describes.

Can I skip the background investigation?

You can choose not to run one. That choice doesn’t create a presumption that you were careless, but you won’t get the presumption a completed investigation gives.

Is my employee handbook a binding contract?

Not automatically. It becomes one only if the manual says, in specific language, that it is a separate employment contract.

Can I let an at-will employee go after a background check result?

Florida lets either side end at-will employment for any reason. The reason can’t be one the law prohibits, such as retaliation or unlawful discrimination.

How long does someone have to file a discrimination complaint?

A complaint under the Florida Civil Rights Act must be filed within 365 days of the alleged violation.

If you’re writing or updating a background check policy after a hire, a screening result, or a handbook question, you don’t have to sort it out alone. Our team offers a free first consultation that is confidential and comes with no obligation to continue. Call 305-990-2300 or send us a message.

The engagement of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. The information on this website is general information about KEW Legal and the services we offer; it does not constitute legal advice and is intended for informational purposes only. Accessing this website or contacting our firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. KEW Legal, 16690 Collins Ave Ste 1101, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160.

What a Written Screening Policy Should Cover

Each Check, Defined

Name every type of background check you use so managers and HR apply the same standard.

The Positions It Covers

Tie each check to specific roles so screening matches the duties and responsibilities of the job.

When Screening Happens

Set the stage in the hiring process where checks run, and how they fit with offers and onboarding.

Who Reviews the Results

Assign responsibility for reviewing results, handling questions and keeping records secure.

Avoid Ad Hoc Screening

Running checks differently from one candidate to the next can create the very risks a policy is meant to reduce. Put your screening rules in writing before your next hire.

Questions to Settle Before You Screen

Which roles need checks?

Decide which positions justify screening and document the reasons for each one.

How are candidates told?

Set a consistent process for notifying applicants and collecting their authorization.

What happens after a result?

Outline the steps for reviewing findings, speaking with the candidate and reaching a decision.

How is information kept?

Limit access to screening records and set rules for storing and disposing of them.

Related practice areas

Request a Consultation

Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.

Call Now — Free Consultation (305) 990-2300