
Employment Law for Employers | Coral Gables, FL
Performance Improvement Plan Review for Florida Employers
KEW Legal reviews performance improvement plans before they are issued, so your documentation is clear, consistent with your policies, and built to hold up if the employment relationship ends. We serve business owners across Miami-Dade and Broward Counties.
By Kristina E. Wilson · Published October 30, 2026
A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a written document that sets performance goals, a deadline and consequences for an employee. A performance improvement plan review attorney checks that document, the facts behind it and the employer’s records before the plan goes out. The goal is to find legal risk while it can still be fixed.
What a Performance Improvement Plan Review Is and Who It Is For
A PIP review is a legal check done before a plan is issued or the next step is taken. It asks whether the plan is accurate, consistent and lawful.
A PIP is more than an HR form. If the plan rests on a reason Florida law prohibits, the employer can face a claim later, even if no one has been fired yet.
This guide is written for private employers. It is for owners, HR managers and supervisors at companies in Miami-Dade, Broward County and South Florida who are drafting or reviewing a plan now.
KEW Legal focuses on employment law for employers. The firm also acts as outside general counsel for business owners and investors across Miami-Dade and South Florida.
If a draft PIP is on your desk after a complaint or leave request, you don't have to decide alone whether it's safe to issue. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

What a PIP Review Covers
A review tests the plan against the facts, the employer’s policies and the law. The main items are:
- Consistency with policy. The plan should match the handbook, the progressive discipline steps and how similar employees were treated.
- Clear standards. Goals should be measurable, with a deadline and a named person who decides whether they were met.
- Accurate records. Dates, prior warnings, performance data and witness notes should match what the plan says.
- Protected activity. The review checks whether the timing lines up with a complaint, a leave request, a pregnancy, an injury or another protected trait. Under Florida’s civil rights law, Fla. Stat. § 760.02 defines key terms, including ’employer’ and ‘discriminatory practice,’ that apply to employment claims. Under the Florida Civil Rights Act, an employer is a person employing 15 or more employees for each working day in each of 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year (Fla. Stat. § 760.02).
- Federal overlap. The EEOC employer guidance is a federal agency resource that employers can review for the agency’s own explanations of workplace topics.
- Workers’ compensation. Florida law bars an employer from discharging, threatening to discharge, intimidating or coercing an employee because of a valid workers’ compensation claim or an attempt to claim compensation (Fla. Stat. § 440.205).
- Document wording. The review looks for language that promises job security or pay the employer does not intend.
Warning Signs That Make a PIP Riskier
A PIP becomes riskier when its timing or its treatment of employees points to a reason the law forbids. Watch for these patterns:
- A plan issued soon after an employee complained about pay, safety, harassment or unpaid overtime.
- A plan issued soon after a leave request or a return from leave, when the file shows no earlier performance problem.
- Standards applied to one worker that were not applied to others in the same job.
- A plan with no deadline, or goals that change partway through without written notice.
- Supervisor messages that tie the plan to age, health, family status or another protected trait.
Florida’s whistle-blower law protects employees who object to practices that violate a law, rule or regulation (Fla. Stat. § 448.102). Under Gessner v. Southern Co., an employee bringing a retaliation claim under section 448.103 that alleges a violation of section 448.102(3) must establish that the employer’s activity, policy, or practice the employee objected to is, by definition, in violation of law.
These claims generally must be filed within 2 years after the employee discovers the action, or 4 years after it was taken, whichever is earlier (Fla. Stat. § 448.103).
How the Review Process Works
A PIP review usually moves through five steps, from the first call to the follow-up.
- First consultation. We talk through the employee’s situation and the documents already in place.
- Document collection. You share the draft plan, handbook sections, past reviews, warnings, emails and any leave or complaint records.
- Legal analysis. We review the timeline, the standards, how comparable employees were treated and any protected-activity risk.
- Written feedback. You receive recommended revisions, gaps to fill and a suggested sequence for the meeting with the employee.
- Follow-up review. We review the record again at the end of the PIP period, or sooner if the employee raises a complaint or asks for leave.
Timing moves fastest when the documents are ready at the start. Gather them before the first call.
Common Employer Questions About PIPs in Florida
Can an employer fire someone on a PIP?
Florida is an employment-at-will state, so an employer may end employment for a lawful reason (Gessner v. Southern Co.). An at-will employee cannot be fired for a reason the law prohibits, such as retaliation or unlawful discrimination (Laguerre v. Palm Beach Newspapers).
Is a PIP a contract?
Policy statements in a handbook usually do not create enforceable contract rights in Florida. They do only if they contain specific language showing the parties agreed the manual is a separate contract (Quaker Oats Co. v. Jewell). A PIP’s wording still matters, because an employee may later cite its promises.
Should we offer severance after a PIP?
Review the severance terms, the release language and any tax or benefit effects before making an offer.
What if the employee disagrees with the PIP?
Write down the response, reply in writing when needed and record every change to the plan.
Does a PIP have to come before termination?
That depends on the employer’s written policies and past practice. The plan’s wording should match them.
Why Employers Work with KEW Legal on PIP Reviews
KEW Legal is a Florida business law firm with offices in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. Kristina E. Wilson is the responsible lawyer for this page. Natalie Martinez is also one of the firm’s lawyers. Our lawyers focus on employment and business-side issues between owners and their workers.
Because the firm works as outside general counsel, a PIP review can connect to the same employer’s contracts, handbook, leave practices and wage rules. A performance problem can overlap with contract or owner-level issues, so the review can look at those too.
KEW Legal cannot promise an outcome in any employee dispute. Each review reflects the documents and facts provided.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Talk With Our Team Before the PIP Is Issued
A PIP can feel urgent when a supervisor has raised concerns, an employee has complained or asked for leave, and a draft is already written. Before it goes out, a careful review can show where the record is strong and where it is exposed.
If a draft PIP is on your desk after a complaint or leave request, you don’t have to decide alone whether it’s safe to issue. Call 305-990-2300 or send us a message through our contact page. Our first consultation is free, confidential and carries no obligation to continue.
How a PIP Review Helps Your Business
Clear, Specific Terms
We check that each performance concern, expectation, and deadline is stated plainly, so the plan says exactly what the employee must do.
Consistency With Your Policies
We compare the plan against your employee handbook, prior discipline, and how similar employees have been treated.
Documentation That Supports Your Decisions
We help you record performance issues accurately and avoid language that could be misread or used against your business later.
Guidance Before the Meeting
We advise on what to say when the plan is delivered and how to handle the employee's questions or responses.
Review Before You Deliver
A performance improvement plan that conflicts with your handbook or with how you have treated other employees can be difficult to defend later. Ask for a review before the plan is handed to the employee.
What We Review
Performance Concerns
We confirm that the concerns are documented, measurable, and tied to the job duties the employee actually holds.
Goals and Timelines
We help set goals that are achievable and clearly stated, with check-in points and a defined way to measure progress.
Policy and Handbook Language
We look at how the plan fits with your written policies, anti-discrimination and anti-retaliation commitments, and any collective bargaining terms.
Follow-Up and Next Steps
We discuss how to document progress, what happens if goals are met or missed, and how to close out the process consistently.
Review Your Performance Improvement Plan With KEW Legal
Related practice areas
Request a Consultation
Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.