
Employment Law for Employers · Coral Gables
Dealing With a Difficult Employee? Get Clear Guidance Before You Act.
KEW Legal advises business owners across Miami-Dade and South Florida on employee performance, conduct and termination questions, so you can address the problem carefully and protect your business.
By Kristina E. Wilson · Published November 1, 2026
How do I effectively deal with a difficult employee? Start by naming the specific behavior, gathering the facts, and writing them down. Then hold a calm, direct conversation and apply your workplace rules the same way you would for anyone else. Florida law sets limits on what you can do, so know those lines before you act.
This guide walks Florida business owners and managers through that process. It is general information, not advice about your own situation. The right step depends on the facts of your workplace.
What Makes an Employee ‘Difficult’ at Work?
A difficult employee is one whose specific conduct is causing problems at work. Common examples include missed deadlines, hostility toward coworkers, refusing reasonable direction, and repeated unprofessional messages.
Friction alone is not the same as a documented problem. You may dislike how someone talks or how they prefer to work. That is a personal reaction, and it won’t support action on its own. Ask two questions instead: What did the person do? What did it cost the business?
How do you solve a problem in the workplace? Describe it in plain terms first. “Ana interrupted two client calls this week” gives you something to fix. “Ana has a bad attitude” does not.
A clear definition keeps you focused and fair. It also makes later discipline easier to explain to the employee, to HR, or to a court. Write the problem as one sentence you could read aloud without adding labels.
A difficult employee can put your business at risk, and you don't have to work through the legal side alone. Our team can talk through your facts in a free, confidential first consultation with no obligation to continue. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Start by Gathering the Facts
Gather the facts before you act on a problem. List each incident with its date, the people involved, and the effect on the business. A missed client deadline on March 3 is a fact. “Always messing things up” is not.
Separate what you saw yourself from what you heard from others. Firsthand observations carry more weight. Secondhand reports are worth checking before you rely on them.
Next, review the employee’s file. Look at past reviews, prior feedback, and any written policies that apply. Check whether the behavior is new or has gone on for a long time.
Long tolerance can complicate later discipline. If you let a problem slide for a year and then act suddenly, the employee may argue you accepted it. Address the issue promptly once you see it.
Handbooks also matter. Florida appeals courts have held that policy statements in employment manuals usually don’t create enforceable contract rights unless they contain specific language showing the parties agreed the manual is a separate contract. Read your handbook closely before you quote it. See Quaker Oats v. Jewell.
Have a Direct, Specific Conversation
Have the conversation in private. Name the specific behavior, state the expectation, and explain what happens if it continues. Keep the talk short and factual.
Try a simple script: “On Monday and Tuesday, you raised your voice during the staff meeting. Our expectation is that concerns are raised calmly and privately. If it happens again, we’ll move to a written warning.”
How can I effectively work with someone I don’t like? Focus on work standards and observable behavior. Leave personal dislike out of the conversation. Conduct is easier to change than personality.
Listen to the response. Write down what the employee says, including any reasons they give. Their explanation may reveal a workload issue, a training gap, or a conflict with a coworker.
Then put the agreed expectations in writing. Schedule a follow-up date and keep it. A written follow-up gives both sides the same record.
Managing Disruptive Behavior, an Unprofessional Manager, or a New Supervisor’s Challenges
Address disruption promptly and privately. Step in during the moment only as far as order and safety require. Waiting days lets the problem grow and makes it harder to tie to a specific event.
How to deal with an unprofessional manager? A peer or employee with a concern about a manager should raise it through the chain of command or HR. Put the concern in writing, with dates and examples. That record protects the employee and the company.
New managers face a different challenge. Learn the team’s history before you judge it. Set expectations early and state them clearly. Get support from a senior leader before you escalate a serious issue.
Your own tone matters too. A supervisor who is calm, consistent, and fair gives an employee less room to dispute how they are treated.
Documentation, Performance Plans, and Consistent Discipline
Good documentation is dated, factual, and free of opinion. Write what happened, when it happened, and who was present. Avoid labels like “lazy” or “hostile.”
For example, a note might read: “On April 8, the employee left the shift at 2:00 p.m. without approval. The schedule showed a 5:00 p.m. end time.”
A written warning records the concern and the change you expect. A performance improvement plan goes further. It sets measurable goals, a timeline, and check-in dates.
Consistency matters. If you enforce a rule against one employee and ignore it for another, the employee may claim unfair treatment. Apply your standards the same way across the team.
Keep coaching, formal discipline, and separation as distinct steps, each with its own record. Don’t skip steps unless the conduct is serious enough to justify it.
Florida is an at-will state. In Gessner v. Southern Co., the Florida Supreme Court restated that where employment is indefinite, either party may end it at any time for any reason. Written policies, contracts, and past practices can still shape what you’re expected to follow.
Legal Lines to Watch: Discrimination, Retaliation, and Agency Involvement
Discipline must rest on job-related conduct and never on a protected trait. Under Fla. Stat. § 760.10, an employer may not discharge or otherwise discriminate against someone because of race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, handicap, or marital status.
Retaliation is a separate risk. The same statute bars an employer, an employment agency, a labor organization, or a joint labor-management committee from discriminating against a person who opposes an unlawful practice or takes part in a charge or investigation. A retaliation claim can arise even when the original concern was valid.
Timing matters for complaints. Under Fla. Stat. § 760.11, a person may file a complaint with the Florida Commission on Human Relations within 365 days of the alleged violation.
Florida’s private-sector whistle-blower law, Fla. Stat. § 448.102, bars retaliatory action against an employee who objects to or refuses to join a practice that violates a law. Under Fla. Stat. § 448.101, the statute’s definition of employer covers private employers with ten or more persons. In Gessner v. Southern Co., the Florida Supreme Court stated that, to prevail in a retaliation claim under section 448.103 alleging a violation of section 448.102(3), an employee must establish that the employer’s activity, policy, or practice to which the employee objected is, by definition, in violation of law.
Workers’ compensation claims are also protected by a separate rule. Under Fla. Stat. § 440.205, an employer may not fire, threaten to fire, intimidate, or coerce an employee because the employee has made a valid claim for compensation, or has attempted to claim compensation, under the Workers’ Compensation Law.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

When Your Situation Calls for a Lawyer’s Review
Talk with a lawyer before you discipline or fire an employee when a claim is threatened, an agency letter arrives, or termination is under consideration. These moments raise the stakes quickly.
You may have inherited this problem, or you may be researching for an owner who isn’t on site. Either way, you’re handling something you didn’t create, and you may not know the next step.
KEW Legal acts as outside general counsel for business owners and managers across Miami-Dade and South Florida. The firm has offices in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. Kristina E. Wilson is responsible for this page.
Is Florida an at-will state?
Yes. Florida is an employment-at-will state, but an at-will employee cannot be fired for a reason the law prohibits. Retaliation and unlawful discrimination are examples. See Laguerre v. Palm Beach Newspapers.
Do I need to document every issue?
Document issues that affect the work, and write them down when they happen. Keep notes dated, factual, and free of opinion.
What if the employee complains about me?
Do not retaliate.
If a difficult employee has you weighing discipline or termination, call 305-990-2300 or send a message through the contact page. Your first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue.
How We Help Employers Handle Employee Problems
Clear Options Early
We help you understand the practical choices in front of you, from coaching and written warnings to formal corrective steps, before a situation escalates.
Documentation Review
We look at your personnel files, written policies and prior communications to identify gaps and strengthen your record.
Risk Awareness
We flag conduct that could raise discrimination, retaliation or wrongful termination concerns so you can plan around them.
Direct Communication
We prepare clear, measured messages to employees and, when needed, guide the conversation so it stays focused on the facts.
Pause Before You Terminate
An employee who has recently complained, requested leave or reported a concern may be protected by law. Acting in haste can create serious exposure. Speak with counsel before making a final decision.
Steps to Take Now
1. Gather the Facts
Write down what happened, when it happened, who was involved and who witnessed it. Keep the notes factual and objective.
2. Review Your Policies
Check your employee handbook, offer letters and existing agreements to see what they say about the conduct at issue.
3. Address It in Writing
Put expectations and corrective steps in a written, dated record so the employee knows what is required and you have a clear paper trail.
4. Get Advice Before Final Action
Before suspending, disciplining or terminating, have the situation reviewed so your decision is consistent with your policies and applicable law.
Get Confidential Guidance on Your Employee Issue. Your First Consultation Is Free and Comes With No Obligation.
Related practice areas
- What to Do When an Employee Causes Problems at a Florida Business: A Guide for Miami-Dade Employers
- Florida Department of Labor Investigation Attorney for Employers: What to Do When an Agency Contacts Your Business
Request a Consultation
Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.