
Employment Law for Employers · Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach
Turn Performance Concerns Into a Clear, Dated Record
Practical guidance for Florida employers who need to address underperformance without creating avoidable risk.
By Kristina E. Wilson · Published November 13, 2026
You’re dealing with a worker whose performance isn’t meeting the standard, and you need to know what to write down. Keep dated, factual notes of each incident, the job rule it involves, and its effect on the work. Write what was said and done, not what you think of the person.
This guide covers what to capture, examples of common problems, how to stay consistent, and the mistakes that weaken a file. It’s written for Florida employers, managers, and HR staff, including family members who help run a business and are handling a performance issue on its behalf.
Why a written record of performance problems matters
A dated, written record lets you explain a performance decision with facts instead of memory.
Florida generally treats employment as at-will. Under Laguerre v. Palm Beach Newspapers, an at-will employee may be discharged at any time, as long as the reason isn’t one the law prohibits, such as retaliation or unlawful discrimination.
At-will status doesn’t remove the need for records. The record is what shows the reason was job-related and not a prohibited one.
Consistent notes also help the employee. They show what was expected, when it was expected, and what happened next. That clarity supports fairness on both sides.
If a performance problem has you unsure which records matter most, our team is ready to talk through your situation with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

What to capture for each performance incident
Each entry should record the date, the people involved, the facts you observed, the standard that applies, and the effect on the work.
- Date, time, and place. Write the exact date and time, and where it happened.
- Who was present or reported it. Name any witnesses and whoever raised the concern. Note how it reached you.
- Observable facts. Write what was said and done. “Arrived at 8:25 a.m. for an 8:00 a.m. shift” is useful. “Lazy” is not.
- The standard. Cite the written policy, job duty, or instruction that applies.
- The impact. State the effect on deadlines, customers, or coworkers, using specific facts where you have them.
Write the entry on the day the event happens, or as soon after as you can. The Pinellas County FACE of Performance Model, a county documentation practice, also emphasizes recording objective observations.
Examples of documentation for common performance issues
A useful entry names the rule, the date, and what you saw. Vague labels give a reader nothing to check.
| Issue | Weak entry | Factual entry |
|---|---|---|
| Attendance | “Always late.” | “Scheduled start 8:00 a.m. Arrived 8:25 a.m. on the date noted. Attendance policy requires arrival at the scheduled start.” |
| Missed deadline | “Doesn’t meet deadlines.” | “Monthly report due Friday at noon. Submitted Monday at 9:15 a.m. Billing was held until the report was received.” |
| Quality error | “Careless work.” | “Invoice listed the wrong unit price. Correct price is on the current price list. Error found by the client’s accounts team.” |
| Customer complaint | “Customer was upset.” | “Written complaint received by email on the date noted. Response sent the same day. Follow-up call logged.” |
| Insubordination | “Bad attitude.” | “Instructed at 2:00 p.m. to finish the cleanup before leaving. Stated he would not. Shift lead present.” |
Factual entries let a reader see the problem without guessing at motive.
Keeping records consistent across employees
Apply the same standard and the same format to similar problems for everyone in comparable roles.
Consistency matters for fairness and for later review. If one worker gets a written warning for late arrivals, another with the same problem shouldn’t get an unrecorded verbal note. Use the same forms, terms, and review schedule.
Keep notes focused on job-related conduct and results. Florida law bars employers from discriminating based on race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, handicap, or marital status (Fla. Stat. § 760.10). Avoid notes that mention these traits, a worker’s health, or anything unrelated to the job.
The Florida Civil Rights Act defines an employer as a person with 15 or more employees for each working day in 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year (Fla. Stat. § 760.02).
Recording the employee’s side and the follow-up conversation
Record each performance conversation with its date, what was discussed, and what was expected.
Write down the employee’s response, questions, or explanation. If the employee gives a written reply, put a copy in the file. Keep a copy of every written warning or acknowledgment you give.
If an employee refuses to sign an acknowledgment, don’t force the issue. Write a note with the date and the words “employee declined to sign.” Have a witness initial it when you can.
Does a performance improvement plan always lead to termination?
A performance improvement plan doesn’t automatically end in termination. The plan sets the next step, and the result depends on what happens after it.
A plan lists specific expectations, measurable goals, a timeline, and check-in dates. The outcome depends on whether the employee meets those goals and on the decisions you make after the review period.
Make sure the plan’s written terms match what was actually discussed, observed, and measured. If the plan promises training or coaching, keep records showing it was provided.
A handbook isn’t automatically a contract. Under Quaker Oats Co. v. Jewell, policy statements in an employment manual don’t create enforceable contract rights unless they say explicitly that the manual is a separate employment contract. Check any handbook language your plan relies on.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
Record-keeping mistakes that weaken an employer’s position
The most damaging mistakes are undated notes, altered entries, and records kept outside the file.
- Late notes with no date. Write notes long after an event without marking when they were written. Label every late entry with the date you wrote it.
- Changed earlier entries. Don’t rewrite what came before. Add a new, dated follow-up note instead.
- Records kept on personal phones or loose paper. Texts and informal notes can be lost or disputed. Save them to the personnel file.
- Sharing details with coworkers. Limit performance information to people who need it for their jobs.
- Waiting, then documenting everything at once. A problem ignored for months, then recorded in one burst, looks like a reaction rather than a record.
Records that show steady, dated follow-up are easier to explain later.
Where performance records connect to other employment issues
A performance file can overlap with workers’ compensation, whistle-blower, and discrimination issues. Review the file before taking action.
Florida law bars an employer from discharging, threatening, intimidating, or coercing an employee over a valid workers’ compensation claim (Fla. Stat. § 440.205). If an injury is involved, check the timing and facts before any decision.
The private whistle-blower provisions cover employers with ten or more employees (Fla. Stat. § 448.101).
An employee who believes the Florida Civil Rights Act was violated may file a complaint with the Florida Commission on Human Relations within 365 days of the alleged violation, or may file instead with the federal EEOC (Fla. Stat. § 760.11). Dated records help show what happened and when.

Talking through your situation with KEW Legal
If you’re handling a performance problem you didn’t expect, you may not know which records matter most. That’s a hard place to be, especially when a family business depends on the person’s work.
KEW Legal serves as outside general counsel for business owners and investors across Miami-Dade, Broward, and South Florida. Its work for employers includes employment issues like the ones on this page. The firm’s offices are in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. Kristina E. Wilson is the lawyer responsible for this page.
Every employment matter depends on its facts, so no result can be promised here.
Can I document a performance problem without a written policy?
You can still record what was expected and what happened. A written standard makes the record easier to explain.
Do performance notes protect an employer from every claim?
Records help show a job-related reason. They don’t decide any claim by themselves.
Should I write a note after a performance conversation?
Yes, write it the same day when you can. Label any late entry with the date you wrote it.
If you’d like to talk through the facts of your situation, call 305-990-2300 or send us a message. The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue.
How KEW Legal Supports Employers
Outside General Counsel
KEW Legal works with business owners as outside general counsel, so employment questions are handled alongside contracts, leases and other business matters.
Employment Law for Employers
Our team focuses on employment matters from the employer's side, including documentation, corrective steps and terminations.
Local Florida Focus
We serve businesses in Coral Gables, Sunny Isles Beach and across Miami-Dade and Broward County.
Confidential First Conversation
Our free first consultation is confidential and carries no obligation to continue.
Do Not Rewrite Past Records
Notes should be written close to the events they describe. Do not alter, backdate or discard existing records. If something needs to be added or corrected, make a new dated entry that explains the update.
Four Habits for a Useful Performance File
Set the Standard
Share the job expectations, goals and policies in writing so the employee knows what is being measured.
Record Facts Promptly
Write down what happened, when it happened, who was present and what was said, while details are still fresh.
Keep It Factual
Describe observable conduct and results rather than opinions or assumptions about the employee's character.
Review Before Acting
Look over the file with counsel before a warning, a plan for improvement or a termination decision is issued.
Facing an Employee Performance Problem? Start With a Free, Confidential Consultation.
Related practice areas
Request a Consultation
Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.