Desk covered with employee handbooks, wage and hour records, and legal correspondence in a small business office.

Employment Law for Employers · Coral Gables

Employee Pay Disputes: Measured Legal Guidance for Employers in Coral Gables

When an employee challenges a paycheck, a commission or a deduction, a clear review of the records and the pay terms comes first. KEW Legal works with business owners to answer that challenge calmly and on the facts.

By Kristina E. Wilson · Published November 15, 2026

When an employee says you owe pay, your first moves matter. Calendar any deadline, keep every pay record, and don’t admit anything until the facts are checked.

This page covers the employer’s side of an employee pay dispute in Florida. It explains what a demand means, how to respond, which records to keep, and how the process usually moves. KEW Legal focuses on employment law for employers and serves businesses in Coral Gables, Sunny Isles Beach, and across Miami-Dade and South Florida.

What Does an Employee Pay Dispute Mean for an Employer?

An employee pay dispute is a claim by a current or former worker that you owe wages, overtime, commissions, bonuses, or final pay. It usually reaches you in one of three forms, and each calls for a different first step.

  • An informal complaint. A worker raises it in a meeting, a text, or a phone call. Don’t agree to a number on the spot. Write down the date and what was said.
  • A written demand letter. This is a formal claim, often with a response date. Calendar that date the day it arrives.
  • An agency inquiry. A government office may ask for pay records. Gather them, and have counsel review your response before you send it.

This page is for owners, managers, and HR decision-makers at businesses in Coral Gables, Sunny Isles Beach, and nearby Miami-Dade and Broward communities. If a demand just arrived, the next few days matter most.

If an employee just sent you a demand for unpaid wages or commissions, you don't have to decide your response alone, and our team can work through it with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

What Types of Employee Pay Claims Does KEW Legal Address?

KEW Legal advises employers on the pay claims below under Florida and federal wage law.

  • Unpaid wages and minimum wage claims. Florida’s minimum wage is set in the Florida Constitution. Claims for unpaid minimum wages under the Florida Minimum Wage Act have their own notice step, covered below.
  • Overtime questions. Whether a worker is owed overtime depends on the job’s duties and pay, not the job title alone.
  • Commission disputes. These often turn on plan language, whether a commission is earned or paid, and how it was calculated. Keep the signed plan and every amendment.
  • Final paycheck and deduction questions. Under federal wage rules, wages must be paid “free and clear.” The rule gives an example: if an employee buys required tools and that cost cuts into required wages, that can violate the law.
  • Pay changes after a minimum wage increase. A new state rate can change what you owe for each pay period, so review rates when the schedule changes.

How Should You Respond to a Demand for Unpaid Wages?

Respond on time, in writing, and only after you have checked the facts.

  • Don’t ignore it. Note any response date in the letter and put it on your calendar.
  • Know the Florida clock. Under the Florida Minimum Wage Act, an employer has 15 calendar days after receiving notice of a minimum wage claim. In that time, the employer can pay the unpaid wages or otherwise resolve the claim to the employee’s satisfaction. The statute of limitations is tolled (paused) during those 15 days.
  • Avoid admissions. Don’t say or write that money is owed before the records are reviewed. A casual “we’ll fix it” can be read as agreement.
  • Keep one point of contact. Route all communication through one designated person. Ask staff not to discuss the claim with the employee or on social media.
  • Don’t retaliate. The Florida Constitution bars taking adverse action against anyone for exercising pay rights, including filing a complaint. Cutting hours or changing schedules after a complaint can create a new problem.
  • Pause before any termination. Florida is an employment-at-will state. An at-will worker may be let go at any time, but not for a reason the law prohibits, such as retaliation, as the Gessner v. Southern Co. opinion explains.
  • Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs can also be awarded. Florida’s unpaid wage fee statute also lets a court award the prevailing party costs and a reasonable attorney’s fee.
  • Keep your reply short and factual. Have counsel review it before it goes out.

Which Records Should You Preserve Right Now?

Keep every payroll, time, pay, and employment record tied to the claim, starting today.

  • Payroll and time records. Federal rules require payroll records to be kept at least 3 years from the last entry, per payroll record rules. Basic time and earnings records must be kept at least 2 years, per time and earnings rules. Those are minimums. Keep the records longer while a claim is open.
  • Agreements and plans. Offer letters, employment agreements, commission and bonus plans, and any amendments.
  • Pay and deduction records. Pay stubs, direct deposit records, and each deduction with its reason and written authorization.
  • Messages. Emails, texts, and chat messages about pay, hours, commissions, or the employee’s departure.
  • Separation records. The personnel file, performance notes, and the date and method of final pay.
  • Auto-delete settings. Turn off automatic deletion in email and payroll software. Don’t edit or “clean up” old entries.
Desk with employee handbooks, wage and hour records, and open legal correspondence in a small business office.

How Does the Employee Pay Dispute Process Work?

A pay dispute usually moves through four steps, and each one builds on the last.

  1. Consultation. Describe the demand, bring the letter, and identify every deadline.
  2. Records review. Compare pay, time, and commission records against the employee’s claim.
  3. Response strategy. This may be a written reply, a request for documents, or a settlement discussion.
  4. Negotiation or proceeding. If the claim isn’t resolved early, it may move to a formal forum.

No one can say in advance how long a matter will take. It depends on the facts and on how quickly records and replies move.

Time limits run on both sides. For federal wage claims, the FLSA limitations rule generally requires an action within two years after it accrues, or three years for a willful violation.

Why Work With KEW Legal on an Employee Pay Dispute?

KEW Legal is a Florida business law firm with offices in Coral Gables and Sunny Isles Beach. It acts as outside general counsel for business owners and investors across Miami-Dade and South Florida.

  • The lawyers. Kristina E. Wilson is the responsible lawyer for this page and is one of the firm’s lawyers. Natalie Martinez is also a lawyer at the firm.
  • The focus. The firm focuses on employment law for employers. Read more on its employment law attorney for employers page.
  • The wider view. Pay questions can connect to contracts, commission agreements, leases, and ownership changes. The firm’s outside general counsel for businesses work covers those connected issues, including contract and vendor disputes.
  • Referrals. If a matter falls outside what the firm handles, the firm may refer you to another lawyer or firm.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Employee Pay Disputes

Here are short answers to common questions employers ask about pay disputes.

Do I have to pay a demand amount right away?

Not automatically. Review the records and the claim before you decide whether to pay, respond, or dispute it.

Can I withhold a final paycheck for damaged equipment?

Federal rules require wages to be paid “free and clear,” so any deduction needs a close review first.

Does a commission plan that requires employment on payday hold up?

Plan language is reviewed against the written agreement, the facts, and applicable law.

Should I talk to the employee directly?

Keep it brief, route it through one person, and speak with counsel before discussing the claim.

Is the first consultation free?

The first consultation is free, confidential, and without any obligation to continue.

Talk With Our Team About Your Pay Dispute

If an employee just sent you a demand for unpaid wages or commissions, you don’t have to decide how to respond alone. Bring the letter and your pay records to a consultation at our Coral Gables or Sunny Isles Beach office, and our team will go over the deadline and the facts with you. Call 305-990-2300 or send us a message.

The engagement of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. The information on this website is general information about KEW Legal and the services we offer; it does not constitute legal advice and is intended for informational purposes only. Accessing this website or contacting our firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. KEW Legal, 16690 Collins Ave Ste 1101, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160.

How KEW Legal Supports Employers

Records Review

We examine payroll records, timekeeping data, offer letters and pay plans so your position rests on what the documents show.

Response Strategy

Before you pay, respond or dispute a demand, we help you weigh the options and the risks of each one.

Outside General Counsel

Our lawyers serve as ongoing counsel for business owners, so pay questions are handled alongside your broader employment matters.

Clear Communication

We explain each step in plain terms, so you know what is being done and why.

Respond Promptly and Carefully

Do not ignore a written pay demand, and avoid discussing the claim with the employee or on social media before you have advice. Keep every record related to the pay in question.

Pay Disputes We Handle for Employers

Wage and Overtime Questions

Disagreements over hours worked, overtime calculations and how pay periods were recorded.

Commission Disagreements

Disputes over how commissions were earned, calculated or paid under a written plan.

Final Paycheck Demands

Questions about final pay after a separation, including any deductions taken from the final check.

Deductions and Reimbursements

Challenges to deductions for equipment, losses or other charges taken from wages.

Speak with Kristina E. Wilson in Coral Gables. The Initial Consultation Is Free, Confidential and Carries No Obligation to Continue.

Related practice areas

Request a Consultation

Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.

Call Now — Free Consultation (305) 990-2300