Opens in a new tab

How to Avoid Fraud Claim in Horse Sale

kewlegal

Selling horses is a tricky business. There are reasons why “horse dealer” has a poor connotation, namely that one selling a horse can be accused of sneaky methods and practices. The legislature in Florida took this reputation seriously and enacted very specific regulations regarding horse sales within its jurisdiction. The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Division of Marketing and Development created Florida Agriculture Code 5H-26.0001 (aka Rule 5H). The rule covers the sale of all horses in Florida, whereas other states only apply restrictions depending on the discipline or breed of horse being sold. Rule 5H requires a bill of sale to be produced by the seller. A bill of sale is in essence a receipt for the transaction. Rule 5H also requires specific information be disclosed in this bill of sale. The additional information that must be included in the bill of sale are:

  1. The name, address and signature of the buyer and the seller, or their authorized representative.
  2. The name of the horse and its sire and dam, if known.
  3. The breed and registry status of the horse, if known.
  4. The age of the horse, if known.
  5. The date of the sale.
  6. The purchase price.
  7. A written statement that the seller is the lawful owner of the horse and can legally convey title. This essentially means that the seller is in fact the owner of the horse and owns it free and clear of any liens. For example, if the seller represents that he/she owns the horse and in fact the proper owner is that individual’s parents, then the parents should be the ones signing the bill of sale and not the adult child. Also, if there is a lien on the horse for providing care, such as board, then the seller must pay off that lien before he/she can sell and sign the bill of sale.
  8. Written consent from the buyer that the buyer is consenting to a dual agent. This is only if the agent (usually the trainer) is representing both the buyer and the seller in the deal. If there is dual agency, the buyer must sign off on it, in writing.
  9. Written disclosure to the buyer of any commissions, consideration or other things paid by the seller to any agent. For example, if the seller is not just paying the trainer in cash but also throwing in another horse into the deal, or some other item of value, this must be disclosed in the transaction.  
  10. Disclose to the buyer prior to the sale if the horse has been treated with specific veterinary treatment within seven days prior to the sale. These medical treatments include shockwave therapy or pulse-wave therapy, acupuncture, elctro-stimulation, internal blister or behind the knee injections of the use of any electrical or mechanical device designed or used to shock or prod the horse for the purpose of increasing speed (excepting the use of spurs, whips or other items regularly permitted by the governing breed association, federation, or other regulatory body).
  11. Accurate disclosure of the medical history when requested.
  12. The following statement: “As a person signing below on behalf of the purchaser, I understand that any warranties or representations from the Owner or the Owner’s agent that I am relying upon in acquiring this horse, including warranties or representations with respect to the horse’s age, medical condition, prior medical treatments, and the existence of any liens or encumbrances, should be stated in writing as part of this bill of sale.” This means that if the buyer is relying on any representations or warranties from the seller, those warranties must be included in the bill of sale, or should otherwise not be relied upon.

So aside from preparing (or better yet, getting an attorney to prepare) a bill of sale, what is the best practice for someone looking to sell an equine?

Disclose, disclose, disclose.

It is always a better practice to disclose medical treatment in writing, especially prior to the sale of a horse. Take for example the following real-life case which was decided in Florida. A horse was injected in March 2022 in the front feet, stifles, and hocks with steroids and hyaluronic acid. Thereafter, the same veterinarian was hired to perform the pre-purchase examination in April 2022. The conflict of interest was not disclosed and the sale was consummated. The seller and the veterinarian also failed to disclose the injections, with the seller only stating the horse had been injected around December 2021. After the sale, the horse went lame with a bone bruise and the buyer sued. The court denied summary proceedings and decided the suit could move forward because a jury would have to decide whether the injections performed in March would prevent the purchaser from discovering the bone bruise during the pre-purchase examination done in April. Coombs v. Mitchel No. 5:23-cv-70 (USDC Middle District of Florida)(9/6/24).

As knowledgeable equine attorneys, we are here to help trainers, owners, and riders with their next sale or purchase!

Kristina E. Wilson, Founder at KEW Legal®

Kristina E. Wilson

Founding Attorney

Schedule Consultation

Kristina is a business and real estate attorney specializing in general counsel services, advising investors, developers, and business owners on acquisitions, development, leasing, corporate formation, and contract negotiations. She takes a practical, solutions-driven approach, delivering tailored legal and business guidance with a strong focus on efficiency and high-level client service.

Before founding KEW Legal®, she worked at Alvarez Arrieta Diaz-Silveira LLP and served as Associate/Deputy General Counsel at Trump Dezer Development, where she managed legal matters for hundreds of entities and joint ventures. She played a key role in major real estate developments—from due diligence through post-closing, and improved operational efficiency by streamlining processes and overseeing outside counsel. Her portfolio includes high-profile projects such as Trump Towers, Porsche Design Tower Miami, and Residences by Armani Casa.

Kristina holds a Juris Doctor from Nova Southeastern University (Dean’s List, with a concentration in International Law), an MBA from the University of Miami in International Business and Finance, and a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration, magna cum laude, from the University of Alabama at Birmingham. She is licensed to practice law in Florida, New York, and Washington, D.C., and is also a certified Title Agent and licensed Real Estate Agent.

She has received numerous industry recognitions, including an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, multiple Super Lawyers selections, and several legal and business awards, reflecting both her legal expertise and professional reputation.

Corporate & Business Law
Real Estate Law
General Counsel Services
Litigation Services
International Business Transactions
Government and Compliance Law
Equestrian Law
Franchise Lawyer in Miami

Summarize This Article

Use AI to quickly summarize this page

Client Success Stories

Justin Gonzalez

11/02/2026

I highly recommend Kristina and the team at KEW Legal! They are knowledgeable, professional, and truly dedicated to their clients. Kristina is great to work with, and the entire team is friendly and reliable. I would definitely recommend KEW Legal to anyone looking for a great law firm!

David Rousso

10/08/2026

Kristina and her team bring a genuinely human approach to legal matters, which made a real difference in our experience. They have advised us on a complex retail lease and a multi million dollar developer subcontract agreement. In both cases, Kristina was more than just our attorney, she was a trusted professional advisor who understood both the legal risks and the business objectives behind each decision. Her guidance is practical, strategic, and clear, and we have developed a great deal of trust in her judgment.

Kimberly Benjamin

10/06/2026

As a property owner and business owner in Florida, I have been thoroughly impressed with the services of KEW Legal. They have helped me tremendously navigate laws that affect business owners and owners of real estate in Florida. I highly recommend KEW Legal.

Robinson Casey

09/10/2026

KEW LEGAL has been our primary business Law Firm for the past several years. They’ve been phenomenal.

Lisandra Corvea

09/08/2026

The Team at KEW Legal are amazing. Kristina is very professional and knowledgeable. Highly recommend their services.

Danielle Dorrego

03/09/2026

Exceptional service from start to finish. The team is responsive, proactive, and incredibly organized. They communicate clearly and stay ahead of every detail. Natalie was professional, efficient, and a pleasure to work with. I felt confident and well taken care of throughout the entire process. Would highly recommend.

Caroll Stephanie Beato Grullon

02/09/2026

Very satisfied with the service. Gercia was always available, friendly, and made everything simple and stress-free.

Hector Peña

02/06/2026

Great service at KEW Legal Firm. Gercia was very attentive, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. She made the process clear and efficient. Highly recommended.

Rodney Wilson

04/09/2025

Thankful for an easy and smooth experience! Thank you the whole KEW legal team and Chief happiness officer Mia! She made the visit great!

Zigmia. Stevens

03/25/2025

KEW Legal has been a true partner in helping us navigate the complexities of business law. Kristina provided outstanding advice on business formation, as well as assisting us with contract negotiations. Their team is always there when we need guidance, whether it’s resolving disputes or managing compliance matters. I trust KEW Legal for all of our legal needs

View More
Team of women of kew team collaborating on laptop.

Get Trusted Legal Support Today

For straightforward legal advice and representation, contact KEW Legal®. Call (305) 990-2300 to schedule your consultation.

SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION